Overall weakness is the norm for this issue, particularly in the bison’s head and around the coin’s periphery. It seems that both broad set distances between the dies and overextended usage of the dies combined to produce so many miserable coins. In extreme cases, the reverse die is so worn that its mintmark is grossly distorted and even indecipherable. Such coins are returned by grading services without a decision. More common are examples having incomplete dates, the first two numerals being washed out. Along with 1919-D, 1919-S, 1920-S, 1925-D and 1926-S, this is one of the most poorly struck dates in the series.
1925-S nickels typically have just average to good luster. In combination with their generally mushy appearance, the aesthetic value of this issue is low.
Varieties:
- Slight doubling in the Indian’s hair ribbon is normal for all coins of this date. Perhaps the most desirable variety is the prominent re-punched mintmark (FS-1925S-501).
- A two-feathers obverse may also be found (FS-1925S-401).
- At least one variety is missing the designer’s initial F, probably the consequence of a filled or overly polished die.
- Finally, one obverse features a retained cud affecting the date area.
| Philadelphia | Denver | San Francisco |
| 35,565,000 | 4,450,000 | 6,256,000 |